Skip to content
LATEST
Global Affairs

Indonesia seeks Google explanation for 19,372 YouTube removals

The dispute puts transparency around content moderation and organised political influence campaigns back at the centre of Indonesia’s online speech debate.

Indonesia seeks Google explanation for 19,372 YouTube removals

Indonesia’s Communications and Digital Affairs Ministry said in a Nov. 20 statement it sought a written explanation from Google after 19,372 Indonesian-language YouTube channels were removed between July and September 2026.

The removals, nearly half of global takedowns in Google’s Oct. 30 quarterly Influence Operations Bulletin, sharpen scrutiny of organised political messaging in one of YouTube’s largest markets, ranked third behind India and the US.

Google said in the bulletin that the channels were removed during investigations into “coordinated influence operations” linked to Indonesia, its term for organised campaigns that seek to shape online discussion. It did not identify who operated or financed the campaigns.

The ministry said Google Indonesia and YouTube Southeast Asia representatives acknowledged in a Nov. 19 meeting that the bulletin lacked supporting detail and could be misread. “Any content moderation action, especially on such a large scale, must be carried out in a manner that is transparent, accountable, proportionate and fair,” the ministry said in an earlier Nov. 19 statement.

The ministry said it asked Google to explain how the channels were detected and removed, including the methods used to identify coordinated activity and whether operators were inside Indonesia or abroad. It also questioned why Google had not specified which accounts were affected or what violations had occurred.

The removals have revived debate over political “buzzers”, a local term for social media campaigners who amplify narratives or try to influence online conversation. Google said the removed channels shared content supportive of the Indonesian government, and one August campaign involving 10,134 channels also posted material “critical of critics of the Indonesian government”.

Ismail Fahmi, founder of Indonesian social media analytics platform Drone Emprit, told The Straits Times that the scale pointed to organised production rather than ordinary political activity. “The scale of this suggests mass production of channels, rather than organic activity by supporters,” he said.

Fahmi’s analysis of Google reports found 27,516 Indonesia-linked YouTube channels were removed over the five years to September 2026. He found 99% of those removals occurred after September 2025, almost a year after President Prabowo Subianto took office in October 2024.

The findings do not establish whether the removed channels were tied to existing buzzer networks or who directed them. Prabowo has said buzzers attacking his programmes were funded by large sums of money, but he did not specify the alleged source of the money.

Separate concerns centre on pressure faced by online critics. Social media users have reported home visits, warnings and demands to delete politically sensitive posts. Amnesty International Indonesia Executive Director Usman Hamid told The Straits Times on Nov. 19 that state and “state-aligned” disinformation created a “chilling effect”.

Public pushback has also remained visible. Critical posts continue to draw heavy engagement, while the #CuekinBuzzer campaign, meaning “Ignore the Buzzers”, has circulated as a response to organised online influence.

Source: news report, The Straits Times, Nov. 20, 2026

More stories

Latest news