Skip to content
LATEST
Business

MTY rejects Foodtastic’s $720m takeover bid

The owner of Papa Murphy’s and Cold Stone terminated talks after a strategic review, while Foodtastic urged shareholders to support its offer.

MTY rejects Foodtastic's $720m takeover bid

MTY Food Group said in a Tuesday press release it ended talks with Foodtastic Inc. after rejecting a $43-a-share proposal that Bloomberg reported valued the restaurant franchisor at about $720 million.

The offer represented a roughly 32% premium, according to Bloomberg, making the rebuff a test of whether MTY’s standalone plan can satisfy investors better than an all-cash sale.

MTY said it completed a strategic review of its business plan and concluded that a sale to Foodtastic was not in the company’s best interest. The company said it formally terminated discussions with its Canadian restaurant-franchising rival.

Foodtastic said it made the October offer and had been “repeatedly rebuffed.” Peter Mammas, Foodtastic’s president and chief executive officer, sent a letter to MTY’s board on Tuesday expressing disappointment with the rejection.

“I have long had tremendous respect for Stanley Ma and the organization he built. MTY is a great company with excellent opportunities, but it has unfortunately not lived up to its full potential in recent years,” Mammas said in a statement.

Mammas said Foodtastic believed the proposal would provide “full and certain value” to MTY shareholders and create a strong combination for franchisees and employees. He said Foodtastic was disappointed that MTY rejected the offer “without engaging in substantive dialogue.”

MTY operates a broad portfolio that includes Papa Murphy’s, Wetzel’s Pretzels and Cold Stone Creamery. The company has faced pressure in parts of that portfolio: Chief Executive Officer Eric Lefebvre said Papa Murphy’s “has been struggling more than our other brands as of recent” when up to 50 underperforming locations were closed earlier this year, according to MLive.

Foodtastic framed its offer as a response to those operating challenges. It said MTY “acquired too many concepts—some good and some bad,” and Mammas said in his letter that improving the portfolio requires patient work that is difficult under public-market pressure.

The two sides remain apart on valuation. Foodtastic said MTY had “unrealistic expectations about its value” and had not agreed to a deal that reflected what Foodtastic viewed as fair value, based on MTY’s business prospects.

Source: news article, MLive, Nov. 5, 2026

More stories

Latest news