Skip to content
LATEST
Business

Leaked Deutsche Bank files test Sewing’s reform narrative

Atlas Newsdesk
Leaked Deutsche Bank files test Sewing's reform narrative

Deutsche Bank faces allegations of persistent control failures after an investigation examined more than 15 million leaked internal records.

The Inside Deutsche Bank investigation describes weaknesses across transaction screening, financial reporting and technology, including problems identified after Christian Sewing became chief executive in 2018. Its account challenges the durability of reforms at a lender that had already faced repeated regulatory penalties.

The investigation draws on correspondence, board records, compliance material and internal reviews. It alleges that Sewing encouraged additional risk-taking, challenged compliance staff and withheld information about some problems from shareholders, contrasting those actions with his public commitments to change the bank.

Control failures span Sewing's succession

Sewing inherited an institution with both leadership instability and longstanding deficiencies: his appointment made him its fifth CEO within six years, according to the investigation. At the May 2018 shareholder meeting, he acknowledged shortcomings in regulation and risk management and pledged a less adventurous approach.

The investigation reports that KPMG assigned the investment bank's customer information its lowest assessment, F4, in each of the three years beginning in 2015. Separately, it describes the Russian mirror-trading case, in which paired share transactions moved $10 billion abroad; Deutsche subsequently agreed to a $630 million settlement.

Older trading records illustrate the difficulty of identifying exposures inside the institution. According to an internal report cited by the investigation, a swap entered into in 2007 remained outside normal risk oversight for years and accumulated losses of $456 million by 2014; staff recorded it through manual accounting entries rather than a trading system.

Payments screening exposes cross-border weaknesses

The investigation says a review conducted in 2020 found that Deutsche had spent eight years failing to perform screening required under US law. The missing checks concerned whether transactions involved specified individuals suspected of terrorism or money laundering, making the allegation about a compliance obligation rather than proof that every transaction was unlawful.

A separate finding concerned Colombia, where the investigation says Deutsche processed over €20 billion for leading domestic banks but submitted fewer than 10 suspicious-transaction reports during one year. According to the same account, Deutsche handled approximately 60% of Colombia's euro-payment clearing in 2019, giving the reported deficiencies relevance beyond its own customer relationships.

External monitors appointed by US regulators criticized the controls described in the 2020 review, the investigation reports. The transaction totals and low reporting count do not, by themselves, establish that the payments were criminal; the reported concern is whether the bank adequately identified and escalated suspicious activity.

Cyber intrusion complicates regulatory assurances

The technology allegations reveal a different problem: uncertainty about what the bank could establish. The investigation attributes a 2017 intrusion at outsourcing provider DXC Technology to Chinese hackers and cites a 2018 internal assessment saying limited infrastructure visibility impaired Deutsche's ability to identify malicious activity.

That assessment contrasts with an earlier assurance to supervisors that the intrusion had not compromised customer or financial information, according to the investigation. The account does not establish that such information was stolen, but it presents a discrepancy between the assurance and the bank's documented investigative limitations.

The unresolved issue is whether the documented weaknesses were subsequently corrected, rather than simply identified. If they persisted, remediation would involve transaction monitoring, accounting controls and technology oversight; if later changes resolved them, their timing and effectiveness would be central to assessing the reform record described by the investigation.

These revelations are likely to trigger renewed scrutiny from European and United States financial regulators, potentially prompting formal enforcement inquiries, expanded monitorships, or punitive capital surcharges. Such regulatory friction could dent broader investor confidence in European banking governance while complicating trans-Atlantic coordination on anti-money laundering enforcement and sanctions compliance.

A major uncertainty centers on leadership durability and the risk of executive reshuffles should authorities conclude that internal risk alerts were intentionally minimized after previous reform commitments. As seen in earlier compliance crises across global investment banks, protracted supervisory interventions often impose severe operational drag, inflating legal expenses and stifling strategic growth initiatives.

On the other hand, a transparent and cooperative posture by the lender could accelerate overdue enterprise-wide digital overhauls, potentially reassuring institutional counterparties if remediation progress is demonstrably verified. In the near term, the institution’s stability will critically depend on whether forthcoming regulatory audits interpret the disclosures as evidence of ongoing negligence or as historical remnants of a complex turnaround effort.

More stories

Latest news