Eurovision, Europe’s Unlikely Export
Eurovision crowns its first Asian winner as Europe’s song contest goes global

ON SATURDAY NIGHT in Bangkok, a Bulgarian handed a trophy to a Filipino. Dara, who won the Eurovision Song Contest in Vienna in May, passed the glass microphone to Carmelle, a 19-year-old whose entry "Sobra-Sobra" ("Too Much") took 211 points, the most from the juries and the most from the public, in the first Eurovision Song Contest Asia. Thailand, the host, was second; Vietnam third. Eleven broadcasters took part. A 12th set of votes came from the "rest of the world," which in Eurovision's cosmology now includes Europe.
The seven delegations that met in Lugano in May 1956 would have found this baffling. Their contest was a plumbing test. The infant European Broadcasting Union (EBU) wanted to know whether it could link national television networks for one live, simultaneous transmission across borders. The songs were there to give viewers a reason to stay. Seventy years later the plumbing is unremarkable and the songs have become Europe's most successful cultural export: a format that 131 million people watched in May, that is now franchised in Asia and that will seat Canada as a full competitor next spring.
Success has arrived with complications. In the same six months the contest lost five broadcasters, including a founding-era funder, to a boycott over Israel; shed 35 million television viewers; and discovered that its national selections are receiving songs no human wrote, with no rule to stop one winning. Geography, politics and technology are testing the thing at once. This report asks how a Cold War broadcasting experiment became an export, what the export is worth, and whether it survives the people and machines now pulling at it.
Ever closer union
Eurovision's map has tracked Europe's enlargements, usually a step ahead of them. The founders were the Western core: Switzerland, the Netherlands, Belgium, West Germany, France, Luxembourg and Italy. Britain, Austria and the Nordics arrived within a decade. Israel came in 1973, a reminder that EBU membership follows the European Broadcasting Area, a line drawn by engineers through the Middle East and North Africa, and never the continent's coastline. Morocco tried it once, in 1980, and left. Turkey sang from 1975 to 2012 and then stopped, in a sulk about voting rules that has outlasted several governments.
The great leap came after 1989. The former Warsaw Pact and the successor states of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union piled in through the 1990s and 2000s, swelling the field past 40 and forcing semi-finals in 2004. For many, a Eurovision debut preceded EU accession by years and carried the same message: we are in the room. Estonia's win in 2001 and Ukraine's in 2004 were received at home as geopolitics with a backing track. Russia was shown the door in 2022, within days of its invasion of Ukraine. The EBU can move quickly when its members agree.
Occasionally the contest also made money for someone. ABBA won for Sweden in 1974 with "Waterloo" and became one of the best-selling acts in history. Celine Dion won for Switzerland in 1988, a Canadian singing in French for a country she had never lived in, a fact Canada's broadcaster will mention often next year.
Australia, admitted in 2015 as a one-off for the 60th birthday, never left. It set the template the EBU now follows: a broadcaster that has aired the show for decades (SBS), a fan base in a non-European market, and a willingness to pay for the privilege. Canada's CBC/Radio-Canada became an active EBU member this summer and will compete in Burgas, a Bulgarian port on the Black Sea, on May 11, 13 and 15, 2027. Thirty-six broadcasters have signed up, one more than sang in Vienna.
Idol threats
Europe sells the world cars, medicines, regulation and football. It sells almost no television formats that carry its name. Eurovision is the exception, and the EBU has spent a decade learning how to sell it without wrecking it.
The first lesson was expensive. The American Song Contest, licensed to NBC and made by Swedish Eurovision veterans, premiered on Monday, March 21, 2022 to 2.9 million viewers. By mid-April it had under 1.5 million and was losing its time slot to ABC's "American Idol." NBC did not order a second season. Martin Green, the contest's director since 2024, later conceded it was "not really our format": a competition among the states of one country, he said, ends up as "The Voice" or "Idol" with flags. Eurovision Canada and Eurovision India, announced in the same flush of ambition, were quietly dropped.
The conclusion the EBU drew is that the product is the contest between nations. Strip out the anthems and the grudges and what remains is a talent show, of which the world has plenty. Hence the pivot, announced in April, to continental editions. Eurovision Song Contest Asia is the first. The EBU owns the brand; Voxovation, a format company co-founded by Peter Settman, a Swedish producer, holds the license; S2O Productions of Bangkok made the show; Channel 3 hosted it; ZOOP, a Thai loyalty and payments brand, paid for the final. The national selections and the final ran on Eurovision's YouTube channel beside local television.
The cast list was modest on purpose. The participants were Bangladesh, Bhutan, Cambodia, Laos, Malaysia, Nepal, the Philippines, South Korea, Thailand and Vietnam, plus one broadcaster added after the March launch. Japan, China, India and Indonesia, the region's four biggest television markets, stayed away. A first edition built on broadcasters keen to be seen, in markets where K-pop and P-pop already travel, is a cheaper launch than one that depends on reluctant giants. The winner's prize, a guest slot at the European final in Burgas, tethers the offshoot to the parent without letting it compete.
Canada's admission runs the other way: a non-European broadcaster let into the main contest on the Australian precedent. The effect is to turn Eurovision into a club with a European core and a paying periphery. Mr Green's phrasing, that the contest "continues to welcome the world" while "born in Europe," is careful. The EBU has sworn off single-country formats. It has said nothing about whether America, Japan or anyone else large could join on Australia's terms.
Two things make this unlike an ordinary format sale. The licensor is a public-service union with no shareholders and a 70-year reputation to lose. And the asset is a live, simultaneous, multinational broadcast, which nobody in seven decades has managed to clone. That scarcity is what the export is worth.
Follow the money
The EBU does not publish a consolidated budget for the contest, so its finances are studied the way astronomers study black holes: by what happens nearby. What happens nearby is that cities keep bidding.
Basel, host in 2025, found 35 million Swiss francs (about €37 million) from the city, 20 million from the broadcaster SRG SSR and 5 million from the EBU, according to figures reported by Austrian media as Vienna weighed its own bid. Vienna capped its contribution at €22.6 million. A study by EcoAustria, a research institute, commissioned before the city was chosen, estimated a €57 million boost to demand against about €36 million in costs, with €22 million flowing back in taxes, roughly what the city spent. ORF, the host broadcaster, counted 150,000 visits to the fan village on Rathausplatz, 97,000 ticket-holders across nine shows, and hotel takings in Vienna of €150.6 million for May, up 7% on the year.
Liverpool, which hosted in 2023 on Ukraine's behalf, is the benchmark: a study by the University of Liverpool and Amion Consulting put the net impact at £65.9 million, with £11.1 million more from visitors who came back the next year. The pattern repeats: a sharp injection into hotels and bars, a longer tail in destination marketing, and a bill the public mostly pays.
Television is the other ledger, and harder reading. Vienna's three shows reached 131 million viewers in 35 markets, down 35 million from Basel and the lowest since 2012, when 103 million watched. The EBU blames the five missing broadcasters, whose audiences no longer count, and points to 5.43 million unique YouTube viewers, up 4.6%, and record engagement among the young. Both things are true. Linear audiences are shrinking everywhere and Eurovision's share on the night still dwarfs the schedule around it. But a product sold to sponsors and new markets on reach has just posted its weakest reach in 14 years.
For Asia the numbers do not yet exist. The EBU has not said what Voxovation paid for the license, what Channel 3 or Thailand's tourism authority put in, or how many people watched the Bangkok final. Those figures will decide whether there is a Bangkok 2027, or an anywhere 2027.
Nul points for neutrality
Eurovision has always insisted that it is above politics, which is itself a political position. The claim exists because the contest is one of the few places where European states compete under their own flags before 100 million people, and because the EBU's members answer to governments and license-fee payers. In 2026 the claim met a question the members could not settle.
The question was Israel. Its broadcaster, KAN, has competed since 1973; Israel finished second in both 2025 and 2026. Through 2025 the broadcasters of Spain, Ireland, the Netherlands, Slovenia and Iceland said they would withdraw if Israel stayed, citing the war in Gaza. At the EBU's general assembly in December a push to exclude Israel failed. Austria, the host, and Germany, among the biggest funders, backed Israel's participation; Germany's SWR had threatened to walk if Israel were expelled. The five left. Vienna went ahead with 35 entries, the smallest field in more than 20 years, and without Spain, a "Big Five" funder absent for the first time since 1961.
Outside the Wiener Stadthalle thousands protested. Inside, Dara won with 516 points, 204 from juries and 312 from the public, a margin of 173 that BNT, Bulgaria's broadcaster, called the largest ever. Juries and televoters had agreed on a winner for the first time since 2017. Israel's Noam Bettan was second with 343. Britain came last, which is traditional.
The EBU's defense is that its members are broadcasters, that KAN qualifies, and that governments are for governments to judge. Its critics in the boycotting countries reply that the same union expelled Russian broadcasters within days in 2022 and that the broadcaster-state distinction is applied with discretion. Both cases have been made on the record; this report leaves the verdict to readers.
The structural point is less contested. The EBU is a union of broadcasters from 56 countries that decides by assembly vote and has no way to suspend a member short of one. It cannot hold the contest together by decree. For 2027 Ireland's RTÉ and the Dutch AVROTROS are staying out. Spain's RTVE, Iceland's RÚV and Slovenia's RTVSLO have until December to decide. Czech Television has reportedly withdrawn to save money, according to fan media; the EBU has not commented.
The expansion abroad and the fracture at home are the same story read from different ends. A contest shedding founders in Western Europe is adding Canada and opening in Bangkok. Whether that is diversification or displacement depends on who comes back in December.
Sing for the machine
The third test is the quietest and may matter most. Eurovision is a songwriting contest with a three-minute limit, and three-minute pop songs are now something software makes to order.
The EBU saw it coming. In August 2023 Jean-Philip de Tender, its deputy director-general, told Bloomberg the union was "reflecting on how we need this in the rulebook, that the creativity should come from humans." In May, at a fan session in Vienna, Mr Green said that "songs will always be created by humans," while leaving room for AI in graphics and staging. As of November the contest's rules contain no clause on authorship. The line is held by assertion.
The national selections, which supply the songs, show the strain. Norway's NRK bans fully AI-generated compositions from Melodi Grand Prix. It received about 1,500 entries for 2027, and Mads Tørklep, its head of delegation, told Norwegian media he reckons 30 to 50 were written entirely by machines anyway; "it is difficult for us to stop the use of technology," he said. Sweden's SVT took a record 4,077 songs for Melodifestivalen. Anders Wistbacka, its project manager, told Aftonbladet he was "convinced" many were AI-made, that the tell was unknown names submitting in bulk across genres, and that SVT has no way to screen for it. SVT has no ban. Greece's ERT has one. Cyprus has barred AI songs from its 2027 selection. San Marino let four into its 2024 final; none qualified, which proves little either way.
The result is a patchwork: 36 broadcasters, 36 rulebooks, and a contest at the top with none. A song written entirely by a model could win in Stockholm and sing in Burgas without breaking any rule the EBU has published.
Three things make this worse for Eurovision than for the charts. The contest's legitimacy rests on national representation; a prompt is hard to carry a flag for. Eurovision has long been a launchpad for writers and producers, and Sweden built an export industry on it; infinite cheap competition for the three-minute slot hurts that pipeline before it hurts established stars. And the EBU's pitch to Asia and Canada is authenticity: real nations, real talent, live. A contest that cannot say who wrote its songs is a thinner export.
There is an irony. In 2020, with the contest canceled by the pandemic, VPRO, a Dutch broadcaster, staged an "AI Song Contest" in which teams built Eurovision-style entries from models trained on past winners. Australia won. It was a lark. Six years on the lark has turned up uninvited in the inboxes of Oslo and Stockholm, and the organization that once played with the idea must decide whether to outlaw it.
The options are the ones every creative industry faces: disclosure, a ban on fully generated work with tolerance for assistance, or detection tools the broadcasters admit they lack. Which the EBU picks, and whether it picks before the 2027 windows close, will determine what exactly it is exporting.
The most portable thing Europe makes
Europe spends lavishly on soft power and has little that people outside Europe can name. Eurovision is the exception, and nobody designed it to be. It is a byproduct of public broadcasting, of an engineering dare in 1956 and of the post-1989 enlargement that gave new states a stage. Its value rests on qualities that resist deliberate manufacture: live, multinational, voted on by the public and owned by nobody in particular.
That ownership is both the strength and the flaw. A commercial rights-holder would have settled Israel's status on audience arithmetic, fixed the AI question with a line in the rules and auctioned Asia to the highest bidder. The EBU can do none of this quickly, because it is a union that must carry its members. So Eurovision reproduces, in miniature, the European project's own habits: decision by consensus, members who threaten to leave, a claim to stand above politics that politics ignores, and an enlargement policy that outruns the institution's ability to digest it.
The analogy should be held lightly. Eurovision is a television show. But it is one that 131 million people watched on a Saturday in May, that has just opened a franchise in Bangkok and that is about to seat Canada. For a continent whose hard power is in question and whose technology exports are thin, the discovery that its most portable product is a 70-year-old song contest deserves more than a smirk.
The three tests are one test. The contest's offer to new markets is something an algorithm cannot supply: a nation choosing its song and the world voting on it. If the song is machine-made, the first half weakens. If nations keep leaving, the second half does. The EBU is betting that the core holds while the edges stretch. Vienna and Bangkok, six months apart, were the first returns on that bet, and they point in opposite directions. Douze points to whoever reconciles them.
More stories
- How did a $4 trillion company miss it?
- In AI We Trust
- Analysis : Inside Manchester City's £830mn 'disguised funding scheme'
- Scientific investigation continues at Durupinar site in Turkey
- Special Report: The Week That Decides October
- Heat risks rise as El Niño intensifies across the tropics
- Bitcoin’s Comeback Is Real. Whether It’s a New Cycle Is the $80,000 Question
- Why Artificial-Intelligence Companies Are Reaching for the Wardrobe
Latest news
- Nvidia investigation puts SEC focus on investor disclosures
- UN Talks on AI-Powered Autonomous Weapons Face Opposition from Major Military Powers
- Russian airspace incident adds pressure to Japan relations
- Iran targets Bahrain radar as US strikes back near Hormuz
- Low-cost fund cuts annual fee by $9,000 on $1 million
- Indian authorities search for 1 sailor after Oman tanker attack
- Atiku aide backs crude-contract review for petrol subsidy
- Sudan drone strikes killed more than 1,630 civilians, UN says

