Skip to content
LATEST
Markets

US favors autonomous weapons guidelines over treaty rules

Atlas Newsdesk
US favors autonomous weapons guidelines over treaty rules

UN talks in Geneva focus on whether to negotiate binding autonomous weapons rules, with the US favoring voluntary guidelines.

The meeting, scheduled to begin Monday, November 16, concerns whether governments should start drafting enforceable restrictions, rather than adopt a finished treaty. The chair proposes negotiations lasting two years; Washington favors a five-year process aimed at voluntary commitments.

Governments divide over legal force

Most of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons’ 128 member states support opening negotiations on binding restrictions. The United States, Russia and Israel have opposed that approach, maintaining that existing international humanitarian law provides an adequate framework.

Russia has not announced its position for this meeting, although it has resisted earlier efforts to pursue a treaty. That distinction leaves its immediate negotiating stance uncertain, even as its previous opposition forms part of the diplomatic backdrop.

The United Kingdom, Germany and France favor negotiating an instrument without first settling whether it would carry legal obligations, according to Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch. Their proposal leaves the central legal question unresolved while offering a route into substantive negotiations.

Military autonomy tests existing protections

The discussions concern Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems, known as LAWS, and possible prohibitions and controls on their use. Artificial intelligence is expanding the development of military equipment, including drones, tanks, robots and submarines, designed to operate with less human involvement.

AI-assisted and partly autonomous weapons have already featured in fighting in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East. Those deployments are distinct from systems that select and attack targets entirely without human intervention, a distinction central to assessing claims about battlefield autonomy.

Campaigners argue that unpredictable behavior by autonomous systems creates a danger of fatal mistakes. The International Committee of the Red Cross says existing humanitarian law does not adequately cover the particular risks these weapons present.

Leaders of the United Nations and the Red Cross, as well as the Pope, support regulation and have warned about the dangers. Human Rights Watch is pressing the convention’s Review Conference to act, with Coyle opposing the delegation of battlefield life-or-death decisions to machines.

Anna Hehir, who leads military AI governance at the US-based Future of Life Institute, says the issue is already practical rather than hypothetical. She points to published accounts of early fully autonomous weapons use in Ukraine, although those accounts do not establish independently verified deployment details here.

Negotiating mandates define the next step

Washington’s proposal would keep discussions focused on nonbinding guidance, consistent with its view that current international law already governs warfare. The chair’s alternative would instead authorize work toward a binding protocol on a shorter timetable.

If governments endorse the chair’s approach, they would begin negotiating enforceable prohibitions and regulations, not immediately bring those restrictions into effect. If the US proposal prevails, the process would pursue voluntary standards rather than new treaty obligations.

The European proposal offers another possible path: start negotiations while postponing the decision on legal force. The immediate test in Geneva is whether governments can agree on a mandate, its duration and the kind of instrument they intend to negotiate.

More stories

Latest news