Skip to content
LATEST
Global Affairs

Kallas faces EU role doubts after seven-member Ukraine talks snub

EU leaders chose a broader negotiation team without the bloc’s foreign-policy chief, exposing tension over who speaks for Europe on Ukraine.

Kallas faces EU role doubts after seven-member Ukraine talks snub

Kaja Kallas was left out last week from a seven-representative European team for Ukraine-Russia peace negotiations, despite seeking the envoy role, Euronews reported in a news article on Nov. 17.

The exclusion matters because Kallas is the EU High Representative, the official assigned under EU treaties to conduct common foreign and security policy, yet her service is absent from the process.

Kallas had travelled to Dublin for an informal leaders’ summit and argued that her mandate covered talks with Russia. “In June 2024, there was a decision by the leaders (on) who is representing (the EU) when it comes to security and foreign policy,” she said, according to Euronews.

She added: “If the leaders want to change that agreement, of course, they may, because it is the leaders' decision, but I think we should focus our energy actually on the substance.”

EU leaders rejected the bid, Euronews reported, citing people familiar with the closed-door discussions. Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni argued that Kallas did not have sufficient institutional weight and advised against her candidacy, according to those people.

The resulting team includes seven representatives and gives the EU seat jointly to the European Council and the European Commission. Senior officials from the offices of António Costa and Ursula von der Leyen are included, while the European External Action Service, which Kallas leads, is not.

The episode deepens questions about the practical authority of the High Representative at a moment when the war in Ukraine spans defence, security, energy, sanctions, trade and accession policy. Atlas360 reported on Nov. 13 that European leaders were already debating participation in negotiations after U.S. envoy Jared Kushner said Europeans would be included, a position Moscow challenged.

Euronews reported that neither Costa nor von der Leyen defended Kallas when asked about her absence. The article also described criticism from diplomats over her style, including her earlier opposition to direct talks with Russia before seeking a role that would involve Moscow.

“If she actually talked to people and consulted with them, she would have known where the dynamics would lead to,” a senior diplomat told Euronews. “Now, events have overtaken her.”

The same diplomat said Kallas was not necessarily wrong on substance. “Nothing will come of these talks anyway. There's no way Russia will engage constructively,” the diplomat said.

A second diplomat told Euronews that Kallas had been “clumsy” in Dublin and said her job was to coordinate foreign ministers’ positions rather than act like a national leader. That criticism echoes earlier friction over China, Israel and a defence expert group that was cancelled in September after opposition from Italy, France and others, according to Euronews.

Germany has also proposed placing Kallas under von der Leyen’s supervision, Euronews reported. For now, the diplomatic line-up leaves the EU’s foreign-policy service outside the Ukraine-Russia negotiating team.

Source: news article, Euronews, Nov. 17

More stories

Latest news