Skip to content
LATEST
Markets

G7 governments face Italian-style surplus test

Italy is the only G7 economy with an IMF-projected primary surplus this year, while its 10-year yield sits below France’s.

G7 governments face Italian-style surplus test

HSBC global chief economist Janet Henry said in a research note last week that every G7 government will need Italian-style primary surpluses to stabilise debt.

The call lands as IMF October Fiscal Monitor figures put Italy’s primary surplus at 1% of GDP this year, rising to 1.2% in 2027, while every other G7 member runs a deficit.

“Every member of the G7 will have to follow Italy,” Henry said in the note, titled “Turning Italian?”. A primary surplus means a government takes in more revenue than it spends before interest payments.

Henry’s argument is debt arithmetic. When a government’s borrowing cost exceeds its economic growth rate, the debt ratio keeps climbing unless the state runs a primary surplus. She cited an estimate by the director of the Congressional Budget Office that stabilising U.S. debt through growth alone would require nominal growth of 7% to 8% a year at current rates.

Henry did not describe Italy as fiscally secure. “Italy is no poster child: the debt stock is still high, but it has run a persistent primary surplus for many years, initially forced by a severe currency and debt crisis in 1992,” she said.

IMF data show Italy has recorded a primary surplus in 28 of the 34 years since 1992. Henry said the distinction is persistence: “Unlike Italy, none of the others are on track for a prolonged adjustment.”

The projected gap across the G7 is wide. The IMF sees France running a primary deficit of 2.9% of GDP this year, Germany 3.4%, the U.S. 4.9%, Canada 2.6%, and Japan and the U.K. about 1.2% each.

The scale of the adjustment remains contested. Zsolt Darvas wrote in the IMF’s Finance & Development magazine in March that France and the U.S. would each need a primary surplus of 1.3% of GDP to stabilise debt, while the U.K. would need 1.8%. For France, he estimated that would require a budget improvement of more than four percentage points of GDP.

Bond markets have already repriced relative fiscal risk. Italy’s 10-year government bond yielded 4.43% at 13:26 CET on Monday, below France’s 4.93% OAT yield. The Italy-France gap closed Friday at 50 basis points in Rome’s favour, the widest since at least 1999, according to TradingView data cited by Euronews.

Italy’s 10-year yield also sat below the U.K. gilt yield of 5.35% and the U.S. Treasury yield of 5.12%. Against Germany, Italy’s BTP-Bund spread stood at 106 basis points, while France’s equivalent spread was 156 basis points, more than double the 71 basis points at the start of the year.

Pantheon Macroeconomics economists Claus Vistesen and Melanie Debono said in a Thursday note that they expect Italy’s spread over Germany to narrow. “We think the BTP-Bund spread will fall next year, more than reversing its widening this year,” they said. “We look for a BTP-Bund spread of 20bp by mid-2027, from just over 100bp at the moment.”

The counterweight is Italy’s debt stock. The IMF expects Italian public debt to reach 137.9% of GDP this year, above Greece’s 136% and France’s 118.5%, leaving Rome exposed even as investors currently price its bonds more favourably than Paris’s.

Source: news article, Euronews, Nov. 17

More stories

Latest news